Friday, July 29, 2016

The Thanatos Syndrome by Walker Percy

Nine stalwart pongids gathered in the Spanish-moss covered forests of Ventana del Sol, walking quite well and beating their chests occasionally as they proclaimed to suffer no ill effects from a little straight-up Na-24.  The testimonies follow:

Bob S:  I think this is between a B and B-.  Some good descriptive writing; I enjoyed the first part of the book.  It spun out of control, and I didn't enjoy the latter part.  I can't recommend this book.  It was intriguing: the whole idea of tinkering with personality via chemicals is still prevalent in our society.  The conflict and comparison of Humanism vs Science, and the Catholicism sanctity of Life vs destroying life via Eugenics.  B-

Dick Arms:  The plot devices were so contrived, really contrived, that I would not recommend the book.  Nothing fit together.  C

Mike:  Walker Percy managed to put the "You" back in euthanasia.  We read his first novel (The Moviegoer) and now his final novel; and perhaps his best and his worst.  The first part, the medical mystery, was intriguing, fascinating, well written.  But when he had the 'bad guys' react to the discovery of their plot with a "Hey, no big thing!  We will save the world!  Come join us!" then apparently he had to think of something to make them really bad - so thus we are into the child molestation by happy (if not hairy) apes.  Or not.  And how do you convince an entire Board of Directors to all drink the molar concentration of heavy sodium? Just the threat of the crazy uncle with the shotgun?  B-

Dick J:  I found the book very frustrating.  I read sections, and said, "Oh, this is very good!"  Then the drinking of the molar concentration Na-24.  B-

Charlie P:  The book started out well - he writes well.  I thought, oh, Science Fiction? Themes were interesting:  science vs humanism.  The Characters were really interesting - Vergil and The Uncle and Hudeen.  The Ending not so good.  I am not a prude, but the worst for me was the perversion of the children.  Now I told my wife NOT to read it.  C

Jack:  I echo Mike and Charlie - I did enjoy the first part, and I wish he would have spent more time on Ethics:  Bob Comeaux and Tom More argument re making the world a better place.  B-

Gary S (guest):  I am not a big reader, and I did not read the book.  But from your discussion tonight, my reaction is that it irritates me to hear of authors completely misrepresenting nuclear stuff - an isotope of sodium would react in the body just like a regular molecule of sodium, not create personality disorders.

Rob E:  I thought he was trying to bring up some big moral issues - it could be good/bad intentions.  The child molestation was unnecessary, as if he didn't already have enough against these guys.  I enjoyed his writing style and his flashes of humor.  I had major issues with it:  B

Friday, July 1, 2016

Ghost Soldiers by Hampton Sides

Eleven survivors of the Sandia Heights White Oaks Death Drive gathered at dusk on the Last Thursday of June, 1945, to compare footnoted history vs popular writing, interviews vs personal appearances, camp guards vs Imperial Army, Rangers vs prisoners, and forgotten vs rejuvenated.  The following MEMORANDUM  To: All Concerned was issued:

Tom G:  I was caught up in the book.  I haven't anything bad to say.  A fabulous job of story telling - back and forth between the prisoners and the Rangers.  I read this and I realize I don't stack up, not many of us do, to the men of this story.  Capt. Prince was just a regular Joe, thrust into this story - the character, the bravery they demonstrated were inspiring.  We would be hard pressed today to find men to match these described by Sides.  A

Charlie:  Not much to add.  Not a great book, but a very good book.  The author did what he set out to do.  A-

Dick Arms:  The side stories added to it.  This is the way history should be told.  The writing is good.  A

Bob S:  I'm a little ambivalent on my feelings on this book.  It did not have the breadth and depth of an A book, but the author succeeded in telling his story well.  A-

Rob E:   Before I was far into the book, I was put off by what seemed to me to be the author's focus on trivial things and his straining to come up with colorful phrases.  Some examples:

 p. 64.  When the Rangers left their base camp, the author made a big deal of the fact that Mucci had shaved his mustache.  Why was that important?  Did it boost morale? 
 p. 117.  When villagers were excited by the arrival of the Rangers, he likened it to John the Baptist announcing the coming of Jesus.  Makes me scratch my head, rather than visualize the friendly village. 
 p. 164.  When entering another village, the Rangers were greeted by the villagers singing "God Bless America."  This is indeed a emotional scene, but his depiction removed all the charm from it for me when he wrote that their "melody (was) charmingly curdled with the occasional stale note."  That phrase curdled my initial enchantment with the scene. 
 p. 165.  When searching for a way to depict MacArthur's well-known egotism, he characterized him thusly: "his incorrigible fixation on the vertical pronoun."  I've never seen a horizontal pronoun - or maybe they all are, except for "I."   I haven't learned the new multi-gender pronouns yet. 

Another aspect of the book that bugged me was the maps.  Several times the author would mention a village or river along the route of the Rangers, and I would turn to the maps and they weren't shown.  In contrast the route of the Bataan Death March was shown with lots of detail.  But, the book's focus was on the Ranger's rescue mission and the maps didn't help me visualize how it happened. 

 So, for the last half of the book I did some skimming - trying to pick out the meat of the paragraph and ignore the distractions of style.  I also decided to focus on the Ranger chapters and mostly skip the prisoner chapters.  From the discussion we had, I realize now I missed some good stuff.  My thinking was that we knew quite a bit already about Japanese prison camps from "Unbroken" and various WWII movies and from annual remembrances of the Bataan March and the New Mexico soldiers who died in or survived it.  But, I missed the individual vignettes that would have made it all more memorable.  My bad.

 I have no quarrels with the rescue mission itself and its heroic qualities.  And I'm very impressed by Sides's in-depth research.  It's just that his telling of the story too often distracted me, rather than helped me understand and appreciate the awesomeness of the mission. Bottom Line.  B-

Mike B:  I felt this book rates up there with Alfred Lansing's treatment of Endurance - a compelling story, well told.  I appreciated so many things the author did - e.g., starting with the massacre at Powhatan prisoner camp to set the stage for the closing horrifics of the POW camps; then alternating chapters between the Rangers preparations and advance, and the prisoners dealing with life in the camps, plus flashbacks to Bataan and "The Hike."  I would recommend to anyone in a heartbeat.  A

Dick J:  I read this book in one day; an OK book, not sure it was a great book.  I felt I needed more.  It was better than [Kilmeade's] Thomas Jefferson.  I can't give in an A; probably a B+

Ron Bousek:  An interesting book about a fascinating part of the war that I knew little about.  For his book held my attention.  Much better than fiction, where the author has too much leeway.  Highly readable for me.  A-

Bob Woods:  If we are to evaluate a book as a book, we must distinguish the book from the story which is impressive.  The author touched all the bases.  If written in three years, especially impressive.  Few books rate an A; this is an A-

Keith:  I would highlight the culpability of the High Command in abandoning 70,000 troops in Bataan.  The carriers were available; they could have been used to help in many ways.  The book had no bibliography of note; no interviews with Japanese who ran the camps.  Some time back I was in Bataan Park and came across a survivor whose name is on that memorial and asked him:  How would you summarize your time?  His answer [also captured in the book]:  "No papa, no mama, no Uncle Sam; no one ever gave a damn."  B-

Kenny G:  This book reminded me of Endurance.  I read it straight through the first time.  A.

And from well outside of Subic Bay:
Dear Ken,

I washed ashore at Ellis Landing in Brewster on Cape Cod on Tuesday and won't be conveyed in a Nippon vehicle off the peninsula until I am freed on Independence Day.  The dangers here are many--great whites, excessive numbers of crazy tourists, and an overabundance of sun, sand and beer.  And if that were not bad enough, when I forded a tidal river yesterday (and although I don't believe it was the Cabu), I came upon hundreds of young people in uniform carrying bows and arrows camped there.  I noticed some signage with the letters CCSC on the fence surrounding the camp, and so I decided to stay low and keep my distance.  Dick Arms may know the meaning of all this, since he has spent some time west of here.  Not sure when I will be reunited with my friends on the mainland, so I am sending you my comments about your book selection from my beachhead in Brewster now.

I found Sides' Ghost Soldiers to be a moving and gripping story.  And even though it was hard to put down, it was at times difficult to read.  The descriptions of the atrocities the Japanese carried out and what the prisoners had to endure reminded me of the horrible tales we read about in Bradley's Flyboys and Hillebrand's Unbroken.  Sides gave horror and honor equal billing and as was the case in the other two books we read, the strength of the human spirit to survive and the bravery of so many who fought for our country were underscored.  It is an important and compelling story everyone should read.  A 

Regards,  Jack

 (at left) the Memorial to those lost in the Hell Ships in Dec 1944.  Erected at Subic Bay, Philippines, 2012.  



Saturday, May 28, 2016

Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli Pirates by Brian Kilmeade and Don Yeager

A gaggle of well-seasoned erstwhile pirates gathered on dry land near the Four Hills and quaffed sufficient rum to produce the following comments:

Dick J:  Thomas Jefferson and the Pirates was an easy, quick read.  I learned some interesting information about a period of history that I did not know much about.  Unfortunately, I think the book reflected Kilmeade's political biases, was not well researched, and was not particularly well written. If I had time I would go and read other books on the period to get a broader view.  I would give it a B- and that is generous.

Rob E:  When I saw that the lead author was a Fox News Channel host, I suspected the book might be political.  NPR listeners would be aghast.  As I mentioned to you, the underlying narrative could have been:  Barack Obama - you're no Thomas Jefferson; Hillary Clinton - you're no James Madison.  But the authors didn't take that sort of line and mostly just told the story in layman, not scholarly, mostly nonpolitical terms.  And, I understand that they were not nautically correct.  But, who in this book's readership would know?  
There are some interesting contrasts that might have been examined.  Jefferson and Madison took the lead in battling the North African Barbarians.  Clinton and Obama characterized their role in the attack on the Libyan barbarian, Qaddafi, proudly, as "leading from behind."  

There are some parallels.  Regime change was the objective in both cases.  The Navy couldn't communicate with Washington, except by cross-Atlantic ships.  Our ambassador and his limited security forces in Benghazi had trouble getting somebody in Washington to pick up the phone.  At this point in time, though, what difference does it make?

Politics aside, I learned something about a period and a war that I knew very little about.  I thought the early part of the book was a little tedious, but things picked up when the big ships and big guns went into action.  Had some of the feel of the Horatio Hornblower novels I read as a lad.

Grade: B

Tom, Charlie, Keith, Ron B, Bob S:   We agree with Jack's comments.

Charlie:  i'm one of the villains who agreed with Jack.  The subject matter of the book was previously unknown to me and was most interesting.  But, it was poorly written.  On subject matter and content alone, I would give it an A, on writing alone a C-.  I averaged these and came up with B-.

Bob Simon:  The most interesting comment to come out of the evening's The most interesting comment of the evening was how a cabal of talking heads at Fox News use ghost writers to write books that they put their names on and then they send out tens of thousands of them to people who follow Fox News and the books garner good sales numbers and appear to be popular titles.

It's an interesting publishing business. 

And from well outside the seven mile limit:

Dear Tom, Won't be able to make the LTBC meeting at your house next week.  Will probably be in Palo Duro Canyon SP that evening enjoying the red rocks, but my comments about your choice follow:
 
I enjoyed reading Thomas Jefferson and the Tripoli Pirates and learned a lot in the process.  I knew nothing about this war and very little about this period of our country's history.  Not sure what I learned in high school.  I am also amazed when two people write a book like the authors of this one and Bill O'Reilly's "Killing Series" with Martin Dugard.  Does the author in bold print do the writing and the other does the research or do they take different chapters and rely on the editor to fold it all together?  It may affect the style of writing, as I thought it did in this case, resulting in a bland vanilla flavor.   B+
     Regards, Jack

Rush Limbaugh has written a series of books on the theme of Rush Revere and his Talking Horse Liberty.  At least there, the reader had an understanding of the audience that was intended.  Here, it was not at all clear – yet the product was certainly not a scholarly historical account.  More of a popularized 200 page quick sell.  Let’s publish a second book while the press is still humming with our first.  I came to this conclusion after reading the book, and reading Kilmeade’s confession in the Acknowledgements:  “Unlike our last book, George Washington’s Secret Six, a subject I had been studying since 1988, this book had a shorter runway.”   Yeah, like 2 years vs 24 years.
One of my colleagues said, “It’s a good story.”  Yes – but poorly told.  To prove this point to myself, I purchased several other accounts of the same time period and have read some of each.  Give Me A Fast Ship by Tim McGrath is really more on the Continental Navy during the Revolution.  But The Pirate Coast: Thomas Jefferson, the First Marines, and the Secret Mission of 1805 by Richard Zacks (2005) is spot on, excellent.  I also highly recommend Six Frigates by Ian M. Toll. 
Summary review:  I would recommend against this Kilmeade book to anyone interested in the subject, in favor of the scholarly Six Frigates, or the highly entertaining  The Pirate Coast. 
Why?  I will give a smattering of reasons against the Kilmeade book:

Lack of naval knowledge:  I have never read a book about the time of Wooden Ships and Iron Men that did not clearly define and specify the armament of the ships.  Saying a ship is a frigate or a brig is not enough – although it would have been a plus if the authors had at least defined those classes of war ships.  Kilmeade seems to go out of his way to blur the armament – several times he says ‘they had more cannons’ but no specifics.  First I thought he was dumbing it down for 12-year olds.  But then I remembered that I once was a 12-year old, and I would want to know that the Constitution was a 44-gun frigate, but the Philadelphia was a 36-gun frigate.  Instant strength stats.

 Kilmeade starts with a list of characters in the book that just adds to the confusion (e.g., Richard Dale and Stephen Decatur are not listed as a master of any ship, yet most others are, including Stephen’s brother James).  Compare with the list that starts The Pirate Coast, where the characters are categorized – including a category of ships!   With their armament!

One more example to demonstrate that this was written by naval neophytes:  on page 122, near bottom of page re the USS Philadelphia:  “One moment she was coursing through the sea at the land equivalent of roughly ten miles an hour…”  Say what?  Are we too dumb to say that the ship was traveling at 10 knots?  But even worse, ‘the land equivalent’ – does Kilmeade not think that 10 miles an hour is the same on land as on sea?  Unbelievable! 

Another place he actually mentions ceiling wax.  Ceiling wax?   What editor over the age of 12 would not know this should be sealing wax?

Presentation:  A few good things:  I liked the historic paintings and the maps – with one exception:  what was the story on the track of Decatur’s Intrepid in the chart on page 147:  It shows the Philadelphia ‘struck’ (surrendered) way up at top of chart, yet Intrepid sails all the way deep into the harbor?  To what end?  I thought they got away after the torching of the Philadelphia!  And we had an American Fort in Tripoli harbor?  Did you realize that?  This chart needed some serious explanations – at least for us 12-year olds.

However, I have numerous examples of where the book drops to a low level of writing.  Often he ‘interprets’ the officers feelings or thoughts, completely unnecessary.  Here is but one example, again I claim poorly written, from page 70:  “Dale hoped that the sight of the frigate, its hull lined with gun ports though which its dozens of guns could be seen, would inspire awe and deter the would-be pirates of all stripes from challenging unarmed American vessels.”  Note again that he doesn’t want to tell you exactly how many guns are actually there – does he consider this classified info?  This is written at some low level – I know that 5th graders would have no trouble with this.  But I consider it poor writing, reminding me of being 12-years old trying to fill out the 1000 word requirement on an English paper.

Many other things pissed me off.  Fortunately for you, I’m not going over all those.
Having said all that, I’m still glad I read this book as it inspired all this research by moi, and I learned many things from the book itself – such as the freedom of movement of officers that were captured by the pirates.  (Toll explains the parole papers that each officer had to sign, to allow such freedom – self-guaranteeing that he would not attempt escape.)  Final grade:  C-   and not recommended.

Note:  Each of these three books begins with an interesting historical anecdote:  Kilmeade’s book starts with the capture of Capt. Richard O’Brien and his crew, to be held for 10 years; The Pirate Coast starts with another pirate attack:  7 ships and 1000 pirates on an Italian port where they capture Christian women and children as slaves, and lists the Sura that justifies this; but Tull starts his book with 8 pages on Lord Nelson.  Why Lord Nelson?  Why indeed?  The guy was 5’ 6” and weighed 130 lbs.  Do we realize our enlisted Navy troops have 3 white stripes on their blue uniforms today to memorialize Lord Nelson’s three greatest sea battles; we should know what Trafalgar did to the naval power ambitions of Spain and France; and we should know that Britain had 800 warships at a time when we had but … Six Frigates.  Riveting stuff.  Tripoli starts on page 145.


I love getting emails... one of the best parts of writing, which is such a solitary occupation.

Anyhow, no I haven't compared my book to Kilmeade's. I am told there are many similarities. One pro-Zacks reader popped that exact question at a Kilmeade tour stop and BK answered gruffly. 
"Zacks's book is more detailed. Next question."

One cannot copyright history. I think he and his co-writer were too smart to plagiarize, so there's not much I can do.

All best,
Richard  [Richard Zacks, author of The Pirate Coast]


Gentlemen:    
               I was particularly sorry to miss our meeting  on Thursday because I had read the book a couple of months ago and enjoyed it.    In addition, Thomas Jefferson played a role in one of my brief articles in Mechanical Engineeringdevoted to history of technology.  Here is the URL.  It shows that Jefferson kept busy after the American revolution: http://ethw.org/Steamboats 
               I still can’t explain what happened  on Thursday.  My Garmin GPS swore that I was at the  right address.  The number on the curb was right; apparently the address is ambiguous.  After unsuccessful attempts to get directions by phone,  I said the hell with it and went home. I didn’t feel particularly well, having numerous contusions from a bicycle accident that morning.
               Bob Woods

Friday, April 29, 2016

The Life We Bury by Allen Eskens

Nine autistic detectives gathered in the shadow of Cabezon Peak to munch popcorn, sit on Frida, and await para Leon while they discussed hard copy accessibility, Islamic pirates, safety latches on the inside of car trunks, stereotyped drunken mothers, and the response time of police sharpshooters.  Some of their observations were captured on a small hand-held recorder:

Dick Jensen:  I liked the story, I liked the characters, I liked the writing.  An easy read, but the last part ruined it for me:  when the sharpshooter shot the guy in the head and everyone lived happily ever after.  B+

Rob E:  I second all of that – the author wrapped it up too much.  B

Dick Arms:  I was greatly bothered by the coincidences and contrivances.  How did the cops get there so suddenly?  B

Charlie:  Good first effort.  Don’t give up your day job.  B

Ron B:  I give it an A for Entertainment, a B+ for crafting the story.  A good adventure/mystery:  A-

Bob Woods:  I read some, hated it.

Ken Gillen:  Predicable but a page turner.  Enjoyed it!  B+

Mike:  Maybe it had some good parts. Maybe it has some well-written metaphors.  Maybe I learned how to perform a wristlock takedown.  Maybe the code should have been worked on a bit more.  Maybe Carl didn’t have to die the night after he found out he had received exoneration.  Maybe this is a B.


Jack Farrell:  I enjoyed this first novel.  Obviously not great literary work, but I thought it would be a great book to take to the beach.  It did remind me of a John Grisham novel:  engaging, direct, clean.  A page turner.  The characters were not really complex, but not flat either.  B+

Saturday, March 26, 2016

Flashman & The Tiger by George Macdonald Fraser


Eight former sergeants of the Border Regiment gathered in the pre-dawn Burma sunlight to review the Sacred Relics of G.M. Fraser, discuss the relationship of Flashman to James Bond, and consider how even fictional cowards and bullies can change the world for the good – or at least for the Victorian Cross.  One by one the troopers took one step forward, saluted smartly, and had their say:

Bob Woods:   What I find most appealing in the Flashman Papers is that the author takes a specific incident and researches the heck out of it.  His meticulous research had me convinced that he was a historian who turned to writing fiction, but as it turns out, he is a journalist who loves research.  A-

Keith:  Looking for a concise summary of Flashman:  Casanova; Lady Killer; rake; roué; wolf; woman chaser.  50 pages is plenty for me; however, the ending was superb.  Dynamic action is good in the short run.   Hearing 40 minutes of Rush Limbaugh gives you knowledge of what 4 hours will be like.  B-

Kenny G:  This is my first Flashman book.  I read “Flashman & The Tiger” story first and thought it clever to mix history and fiction.  B+ for that story.   However, the Baccarat story was overdrawn, turned me off:  C+   Overall:  B-

Bob Simon:  I read the first and last story, not the one about Baccarat.  I enjoyed the ending to the first story, thought it clever:  A-  I loved the energy of the story – invigorating.  Even humorous writers don’t have this energy.  Good ol’ Flashy goes in, gets the woman, fights his way out – wild!  He saves Franz Joseph from being assassinated, gets high commendations.  Interesting, but not sure I would recommend to others.  Charming, a genre I’m not familiar with.  I don’t know how Fraser animates his artistic genre.  A-

Charlie:  Fun and entertaining, I enjoyed reading it.  Doesn’t compare well with Western Literature.  Doesn’t make it to the top level – very good, but B overall.  Good fun.

Dick Arms:  I enjoyed it.  I read the first part, then learned I was supposed to read the third part.  Very skillfully written, excellent grasp of history, loved where he was idololizing his granddaughter only to discover that she had his same sense of morals.  Skillfully done, probably not tell all my friends to read it.  A-

Mike:  If the twin goals of reading are for entertainment and to learn, this was a top-notch book.  I am always amazed with how little of human history I know.  Especially entertaining to read Flashman on a Kindle iPad app.  
Here one can click on words like Isandl'wana and impi, and people like Cetshwayo and Lord Chelmsford to try to ascertain:  are these fictional or real?  Great mixture of both, and I subsequently learned a great deal.  My thanks to Brother Simon for introducing me to the movie "Zulu" – at YouTube.com, a search for Zulu chants brings 6 minutes of unforgettable video.  A-

… and from well outside of Zululand …

Dear Bob,

Sorry I won't be able to join in the conversation on Thursday.  We will be RVing in northern Arizona far from the threat of Hungarian fanatics, Gordon-Cumming, and Zulus.

I purchased the First Anchor Books 1999 edition of Flashman and the Tiger and read all three extracts.  I did not enjoy "The Subtleties of Baccarat" as much as I did "The Road to Charring Cross" and "Flashman and the Tiger."  These were the first works by George MacDonald Fraser I had ever read.  I enjoyed them very much.  They were fun, if not alway funny--British humor doesn't always tickle my fancy.  Harry Flashman is a protagonist I had difficulty identifying with (still trying to imagine a cowardly Indiana Jones or James Bond), but GMF was successful in keeping me in suspense in every one of Sir Harry's adventures.  A-

Regards,

Jack


Bob and Mike:
I will not be at the meeting tonight.
Here is my brief review of the book.
I enjoyed reading Flashman and The Tiger,  I think it was quite well written and I found the characters interesting--the story was also quite interesting.  I planned to read more stories about Flashman (the book that I bought has two more stories in it) but I was not able to read them--we have been out of town on a cruise.
I don't think this story was quite as good as some of the previous ones that we have read so I would give it a B.


Sorry to miss the meeting.
Dick Jensen

The first Flashman tale we read [2000] led me to regard the hero as a lovable scalawag.  I didn't think our hero was very lovable in this Tiger tale.  Closer to loathsome.  Glad it was short.

C plus.  The plus is for brevity.

Rob

Sunday, February 28, 2016

Divided or United? by LTBC Poet laureate, Prof. Keith Gilbert


Our Nation of some 325 Million
are deeply divided on many issues …
So, are we still a United States?

Our Nation is a curious quilt … indeed,
An amalgam of multiply-cultured
Colored threads … interwoven into a
Sinewy, random pattern…

Our Quilt is so spectrally & spiritually
In-homogeneous as to defy description …but
Note:  our quilt has a triad of Unique Properties

                Our tightly-woven fabric is super strong,
                Yielding warmth & security to its People …
                Yet our Quilt is replete with wrinkles …
                                - Prodigious power & wealth of the 1%
                                - Ubiquitous drugs & crime
                                - unabated conflicts with far-flung “enemies,” etc

             But note … an obvious foible in our Quilt is
             A gaping hole at its center – indeed,
             Our beautiful Quilt is so polarized that
             It has no center!

So, pray tell, what elixirs bend our Quilt?
Again, we enjoy three powerful epoxies …
Faith, Freedom, & Hope …

1)       Our Nation is one of Formidable Faith …
   A Superior Being provides a Radiant Laser
   To guide & nurture us
2)      Our Constitution ensures enduring Freedoms,
   Including Speech, Religion, Press, Petition, and
   The Right to Bear Arms
3)      Our Faith & Liberties Engender Hope …
  Belief in a Chance to Live a good Life
  And seek a better one

So this is why our Unique Quilt unites us
even without a Center
due to Extreme Political Polarization

Yet the Tenacious trio of Goods -
Our Faith & Indelible Freedoms engender
Patriotism and enable Hope.

Though our Nation will continue to debate
Much, the enduring Health and Strength of our
Uniquely-woven Quilt assures we
Will forever remain United.


-          K. Gilbert, Jan 2016

The Longest Road by Philip Caputo

Eleven road scholars arrived at the northern end of Dalton Road and took up residence at the Aurora Hotel, the only 4-star in Deadhorse.  They ate everything on the large banquet table, and then trucked on to examine WHAT (What Holds America Together):

Jack:  I enjoyed it primarily because it reminded me of our family’s Road Adventures – it inspired me to press on.  Not a classic, but a lot of fun.  B+

Dick J:  Same grade; the author writes well, but did not follow through on his stated purpose.  My mind wanders as he writes – where will he go next?  The best part was what was perhaps made up:  the conflict in Anacortes.  B+

Rob E:  I liked it a lot.  I especially enjoy the Great Plains more than the Rockies.  It makes me want to go back and drive them again.  I like the travel books:  Blue Highways (traveling on the back roads) is very good.  There was some expose not too long ago that a good portion of Travels With Charlie was made up.  But the story of the black kid walking through a white school and receiving all the taunts hit me strong.  I liked the stories; the author was cynically looking for angry people. I give it an A- for memories.

Dick Arms:  First, that is an interesting concept:  what holds America together?  The author came across as very negative – not the same politics as mine.  His writing was passable, not great.  I presented this idea at Toastmasters, and got better ideas.  America is unique – a unique political system or a belief system – and a Constitution.  Caputo didn’t hit on that idea.  B-  Just a travel book.

Bob Woods:  To begin with, I don’t like driving long distances.  The book is harmless enough.  “What Holds America Together’ is just an excuse.  B+

Mike:  Why do we read?  I think to learn, and to entertain ourselves.  This book had both.  I enjoyed what the author had to teach about places, cultures, people.  I was entertained by the on-going post 9-11 street corner in Anacortes, WA.  Does an excellent job of his descriptions, always something new.  A

Charlie:  This guy is any writer, who took a vacation, wrote about it – didn’t get his goal, lightweight:  C

Ken G:  I found it often tedious and boring, other times interesting and humorous.  Not any profound conclusion as to WHAT.  B-

Bob S:  I have the same feeling about the premise:  he didn’t analyze why America holds together.  The other part I didn’t care for:  Kit Carson was an active participant in history; Jack Kerouac was an active participant in our Culture – he defined the beat generation and the hippie generation.  It’s true, this was a charming book, well written.  I didn’t find it illuminating.  It did not have gravitas or significance.  B 

Keith:  I already mentioned that the author failed his mission.  C  Here is mine:


Ron Bousek:  There was a lack of summary but he reported what he found.  I liked the road trip with some history along the way.  What holds the country together (as defined by Erika at the end) was Hope – hope that things that are bad will get better.  The writing was not first rate.  A-

... and here is what the author said about his own book:  
I think you’ll find The Longest Road very different from A Rumor of War. It’s a semi-serious, semi-light-hearted travelogue. It doesn’t provide an answer to the question, What holds this vast, diverse country together. But it presents the thoughts that the people I met along the way have on that issue.